J.D. Salinger died yesterday, and so I can’t help but think about Catcher in the Rye. Like most people, I read it in high school. I hated it. I hated just about every moment of it. I hated the slang, I hated the dated values, and I especially hated that I was supposed to care about a self-centered, arrogant, whiny d-bag who can’t get his life together. I sighed and rolled my eyes and did my work and didn’t think about it again for years.
As a teenager, adulthood promised me freedom, and I couldn’t understand at all why Holden would resist growing up. I longed to grow up! I counted the days until the start of college and I waited for that sigh of relief, that exhalation of self-possession and confidence that meant I was, finally, grown-up. Free. I waited. Any moment now. It’s coming…
But that moment never came. Everything was structured. Routine, routine, routine. There was no spontaneity. People were jerks to one another, for no reason at all. But mostly, I felt distant. I had this great big sense of wonder in the world, and I felt things with such overpowering emotions: compassion that made me cry at headlines, anger at injustice that would make me stew for days, and despondency that the world I lived in would never, ever improve.
I felt betrayed. And suddenly, I understood Holden Caulfield.
So I decided to re-read it. I must’ve read it in one sitting because I don’t recall even coming up for air. I devoured it. The archaic language was still distancing to me as a modern reader, and Holden was still a little prick most of the time, but suddenly, having left home and embarked on my own pseudo-adulthood, I felt for Holden. My heart broke for him, and for myself. I loved his love for Phoebe and his painful sincerity. I, too, ached to live in the rye: a world of generosity, kindness, impulse, earnestness! To believe, to really innately know and feel that there was goodness everywhere, and that I and everyone else were a part of it.
I couldn’t imagine ever feeling that way again. If it was out there, I couldn’t connect to it. And you can never go back. You can’t save anyone. You just watch them fall, over and over and over again. My little sister would, eventually. And suddenly I felt such despair, such heart-wrenching anger and hatred and ambivalence at the end of my childhood.
In between those readings, the book hadn’t changed. I did. And nothing brought my own Fall, my own exile from paradise, into sharper relief than looking back at how innocent I was to have read that book and not understood.
So J.D. Salinger, rest in peace, and thank you for The Catcher in the Rye.